Can a Landlord Ask for Financial institution Statements? Aturannya Gimana?

Can a landlord ask for financial institution statements? Nah, ini nih pertanyaan yang bikin para penyewa pada mikir. Bukan cuma mikir doang, tapi juga harus tau apa aja aturannya. Kan sayang kalau kena masalah sama si tuan rumah gara-gara salah langkah. Kita bahas tuntas, biar semua jelas, mulai dari dasar hukumnya sampe guidelines aman buat penyewa dan pemilik rumah.

Jangan sampai salah paham, nanti malah ribut. Kita telusuri aturannya, biar aman-aman aja. Dari situ bisa dibedain mana yang sah dan mana yang nggak.

Table of Contents

Prison Foundation for Soliciting for Financial institution Statements

Landlords, in sure scenarios, would possibly request financial institution statements from tenants. On the other hand, such requests aren’t all the time permissible and should adhere to express prison frameworks and instances. The legality of those requests varies considerably throughout jurisdictions, influenced through native landlord-tenant regulations.Figuring out the prison foundation for those requests is the most important for each landlords and tenants to keep away from disputes and make sure compliance with the legislation.

This phase will element the prison frameworks governing landlord-tenant relationships in several jurisdictions and Artikel the precise instances beneath which a landlord may legally request financial institution statements from a tenant.

Prison Frameworks Governing Landlord-Tenant Relationships

Landlord-tenant regulations range significantly throughout nations or even inside of states or provinces. Those regulations outline the rights and duties of each landlords and tenants, together with the permissible grounds for in the hunt for monetary knowledge.

Landlords ceaselessly need evidence of your monetary balance, however can they ask for financial institution statements? The specifics range, however in lots of circumstances, they are able to request them to evaluate your skill to pay hire. That is particularly related when bearing in mind the awe-inspiring Grand Canyon of the Stikine River, grand canyon of the stikine river , a really impressive herbal marvel.

On the other hand, it’s critical to grasp the prison limitations and your rights in terms of offering monetary paperwork on your landlord.

Particular Cases Permitting Financial institution Remark Requests

Landlords would possibly legally request financial institution statements in scenarios the place there is a cheap suspicion of a tenant’s skill to fulfill monetary responsibilities, specifically regarding hire bills. That is ceaselessly tied to express clauses in hire agreements or appropriate regulations.

Landlords typically can not call for your financial institution statements until there is a particular clause to your hire. On the other hand, if your own home is unexpectedly reeking of nail polish remover, like on this contemporary article about house smells like nail polish remover , it could be a unique tale. A landlord may wish to see evidence you are dealing with the problem, doubtlessly making financial institution statements related.

So, whilst normally a no-go, the specifics rely on your hire and the location.

Permissible Causes for Looking for Monetary Data

A landlord may request monetary knowledge for a valid reason why, corresponding to verifying the tenant’s skill to pay hire. On the other hand, the request should be proportionate to the suspected chance. For instance, if a tenant has a constant charge historical past, a request for detailed financial institution statements may not be justified. The scope of the asked knowledge must be restricted to what’s without delay related to the owner’s worry.

Barriers on Soliciting for Monetary Data

Landlords can not use financial institution statements to discriminate towards tenants in line with safe traits. The request must be tied to the tenant’s skill to pay hire and no longer in line with components corresponding to race, faith, or gender. Additionally, over the top or unwarranted requests for monetary knowledge are ceaselessly thought to be violations of privateness and tenant rights.

Comparability of Landlord-Tenant Regulations Throughout Jurisdictions

Jurisdiction Prison Foundation for Financial institution Remark Request Permissible Causes Barriers
United States (Instance: California) In response to state-specific landlord-tenant regulations and hire agreements. Verifying skill to pay hire, assessing monetary chance, or addressing attainable defaults. Requests should be cheap and proportionate; can’t be discriminatory.
United Kingdom Guided through not unusual legislation and particular tenancy agreements. Setting up the tenant’s skill to fulfill monetary responsibilities, addressing attainable breaches of contract. Requests should be justified and no longer intrusive.
Canada (Instance: Ontario) Ruled through provincial landlord-tenant regulation. Very similar to the United States; verifying charge skill, addressing attainable defaults. Requests should be in step with prison requirements and tenant rights.

The desk above supplies a basic comparability; particular regulations and rules inside of every jurisdiction must be consulted for correct and detailed knowledge. Landlords and tenants must all the time confer with the related native regulation for essentially the most up-to-date and correct knowledge.

Kinds of Financial institution Statements and Data

Can a Landlord Ask for Financial institution Statements?  Aturannya Gimana?

Landlords would possibly request financial institution statements to evaluate a tenant’s monetary balance and skill to fulfill condominium responsibilities. Figuring out the permissible sorts and main points of those statements is the most important for each tenants and landlords. This phase delves into the appropriate forms of statements, the allowed monetary knowledge, and the time frame for requests.

Permissible Kinds of Financial institution Statements

Landlords are in most cases authorised to request financial institution statements for checking and financial savings accounts, reflecting the tenant’s number one source of revenue assets. In some instances, industry accounts can also be asked, particularly if the tenant’s number one source of revenue is derived from a industry. On the other hand, the precise necessities range through jurisdiction and the character of the condominium settlement.

Permissible Monetary Data

Landlords can read about account balances, transaction historical past, and deposits to evaluate the tenant’s source of revenue and monetary balance. On the other hand, the precise monetary main points {that a} landlord can overview are restricted to these without delay related to the tenant’s skill to pay hire. Data corresponding to mortgage main points, funding accounts, or private money owed, whilst doubtlessly to be had within the statements, are in most cases no longer permissible for overview.

Time Body for Requests

The time-frame for asking for financial institution statements is ceaselessly dictated through the precise condominium settlement and native rules. A landlord’s request must be cheap and no longer unduly burdensome to the tenant. It is really helpful to obviously specify the period of time for which statements are required. As an example, a landlord would possibly ask for the ultimate 3 months’ statements to evaluate the tenant’s contemporary monetary job.

Permissible vs. Prohibited Data in Financial institution Statements

Permissible Data Prohibited Data
Account stability Funding account main points
Transaction historical past (hire bills, deposits) Mortgage main points
Deposit historical past (appearing common source of revenue) Private money owed (except hire bills)
Checking and financial savings account job (related to condominium bills) Industry account job (until particularly associated with condominium source of revenue)

The desk above highlights the adaptation between permissible and prohibited knowledge landlords can request in financial institution statements. The point of interest must be at the tenant’s skill to pay hire, no longer on different private monetary issues.

Tenant Rights and Protections

Tenants possess the most important rights safeguarding them from unwarranted requests for monetary knowledge through landlords. Those rights stem from quite a lot of prison frameworks and tenant coverage regulations, which purpose to strike a stability between a landlord’s reliable want for monetary assurance and a tenant’s proper to privateness. Figuring out those protections is essential for each tenants and landlords to keep away from attainable disputes.Tenant rights referring to monetary disclosures to landlords are ceaselessly nuanced and rely closely at the particular jurisdiction and the character of the condominium settlement.

Whilst landlords could have reliable causes for in the hunt for monetary knowledge, corresponding to verifying a tenant’s skill to pay hire, those requests should adhere to prison pointers. A tenant’s refusal to offer knowledge must no longer be routinely interpreted as a loss of monetary balance.

Tenant’s Rights Relating to Disclosure of Monetary Data

Tenants are typically no longer obligated to reveal financial institution statements or different monetary knowledge until explicitly required through the phrases of the hire settlement or through appropriate legislation. A landlord’s request for such knowledge should be justified and no longer exceed the vital scope. As an example, a landlord can not call for detailed account knowledge past what is vital to evaluate a tenant’s skill to pay hire.

This contains, however isn’t restricted to, the tenant’s credit score historical past or references.

Tenant Recourse for Fallacious Requests

If a landlord makes an mistaken request for financial institution statements or different monetary knowledge, tenants have recourse thru prison channels. This will likely come with submitting a criticism with the related housing authority or pursuing prison motion towards the owner. It is very important for tenants to report such a requests and the owner’s reaction. Detailed data of communications, together with emails, letters, or verbal conversations, are the most important in supporting any attainable prison declare.

Examples of Tenant Protections In opposition to Unfair Requests

More than a few prison protections defend tenants from over the top or irrelevant calls for for monetary knowledge. Those protections can range in line with native rules and the specifics of a hire settlement. For instance, some jurisdictions would possibly limit landlords from asking for financial institution statements and not using a demonstrably legitimate reason why, corresponding to a historical past of past due hire bills. In a similar fashion, some jurisdictions would possibly mandate particular procedures for such requests.

Those rules purpose to forestall landlords from abusing their energy and make sure honest remedy for tenants.

Doable Penalties for Landlords Making Beside the point Requests

Beside the point Request Doable Penalties
Soliciting for over the top monetary knowledge past what is vital to evaluate charge capability Conceivable prison motion through tenants, fines, or consequences imposed through housing government.
Soliciting for monetary knowledge and not using a reliable reason why or justification Doable prison repercussions, injury to landlord-tenant relationships, and damaging affect on popularity.
Failure to conform to native rules referring to monetary disclosure requests Prison motion, fines, and consequences from related government.

Landlords should appreciate tenant privateness rights and no longer have interaction in practices which are discriminatory or unreasonable.

Objective of Soliciting for Financial institution Statements

Can a landlord ask for bank statements

Landlords would possibly request financial institution statements from tenants for reliable causes associated with the tenancy settlement and the monetary accountability of the tenant. On the other hand, no longer all requests are justified, and a few is also thought to be abusive or irrelevant. Figuring out the permissible causes for such requests is the most important for each landlords and tenants to deal with an excellent and legally sound tenancy courting.A landlord’s request for financial institution statements is typically connected to verifying the tenant’s skill to satisfy monetary responsibilities, corresponding to hire bills.

The legality and appropriateness of the request rely at the particular context and the character of the tips sought. This phase delves into the reliable grounds for asking for financial institution statements, along examples of justified and unwarranted requests.

Respectable Functions for Soliciting for Financial institution Statements

Figuring out the permissible causes in the back of a landlord’s request for financial institution statements is very important. Those causes ceaselessly relate to the tenant’s skill to fulfill monetary responsibilities, making sure the protection of the condominium assets, and combating attainable monetary hurt to the owner.

  • Verifying Hire Cost Skill: A landlord would possibly request financial institution statements to evaluate the tenant’s constant source of revenue and capability to hide per month hire bills. This is helping mitigate the chance of hire arrears and attainable monetary pressure at the landlord.
  • Assessing Monetary Steadiness: A landlord would possibly request financial institution statements to gauge the tenant’s total monetary balance. This may give insights into the tenant’s skill to control bills and meet different monetary responsibilities, contributing to a extra safe tenancy settlement.
  • Fighting Fraudulent Actions: In sure instances, financial institution statements is also asked to forestall attainable fraudulent actions, corresponding to using fraudulent id or monetary tools. This safeguard protects the owner’s assets and monetary pursuits.
  • Imposing Hire Agreements: In some circumstances, hire agreements would possibly explicitly allow the owner to request monetary knowledge as a part of the settlement. The request should align with the clauses within the hire and be inside of prison limitations.

Examples of Justified Requests

A justified request for financial institution statements ceaselessly arises from a transparent wish to evaluation the tenant’s skill to satisfy their responsibilities beneath the hire settlement.

  • Constant Hire Bills: A tenant persistently past due with hire bills could be requested to offer financial institution statements to turn enough finances for the per month hire.
  • Huge Hire Quantities: For homes with top condominium charges, a landlord may request financial institution statements to substantiate the tenant’s skill to hide such bills and deal with monetary balance.
  • Suspicious Transactions: If a tenant’s monetary transactions display extraordinary or suspicious patterns, a landlord would possibly request financial institution statements to research and cope with attainable problems.

Examples of Unwarranted or Abusive Requests

It is the most important to acknowledge circumstances the place a financial institution remark request is irrelevant or doubtlessly abusive.

  • Normal Scrutiny: A landlord can not automatically request financial institution statements from all tenants and not using a legitimate reason why associated with the hire settlement.
  • Over the top Data: Requests for over the top private monetary knowledge this is indirectly related to the tenancy settlement are irrelevant.
  • Discrimination: A request for financial institution statements in line with discriminatory components, corresponding to race, faith, or gender, is exactly prohibited.

Desk: Legality of Financial institution Remark Requests

Objective of Request Prison? Clarification
Verifying hire charge skill Sure Respectable reason why to evaluate monetary capability
Assessing total monetary balance Sure Legitimate if connected to pleasurable responsibilities
Fighting fraud Sure Protects landlord from monetary hurt
Imposing hire agreements Sure If authorised through hire phrases
Normal scrutiny of all tenants No Unjustified and most likely unwarranted
Over the top private monetary main points No Beside the point and is going past tenancy
Discriminatory causes No Unlawful and unethical

Drafting a Letter Soliciting for Financial institution Statements

Landlords ceaselessly require financial institution statements from tenants to evaluate their monetary balance and skill to fulfill condominium responsibilities. This procedure, when carried out accurately, protects each events’ pursuits. On the other hand, the request should adhere to prison pointers and tenant rights.This phase main points the the most important parts of a legally sound letter asking for financial institution statements, outlining each landlord and tenant views. It supplies pattern letters let’s say highest practices and examples of easy methods to keep away from attainable problems.

It emphasizes the significance of readability, legality, and appreciate for tenant rights in those communications.

Very important Components of a Landlord’s Letter

The letter must obviously state the aim of the request and the precise time frame for offering the statements. The owner should give an explanation for why the request is vital, adhering to prison necessities and tenant rights.

  • Objective of the Request: The letter must explicitly state the cause of asking for the financial institution statements. For instance, it may well be to evaluate the tenant’s skill to fulfill long run condominium responsibilities or to ensure the accuracy of source of revenue knowledge in the past supplied. This readability is very important to forestall misunderstandings and attainable prison demanding situations.
  • Particular Time-frame: The letter must obviously specify the date wherein the tenant should give you the statements. A cheap time frame must be set, bearing in mind the processing time for the statements. For instance, “Please supply your financial institution statements overlaying the duration from [Start Date] to [End Date] through [Date].”
  • Transparent Directions: The letter must supply particular directions on how the tenant must give you the statements. As an example, “Please put up the statements by the use of e-mail to [Email Address] in PDF structure.” This guarantees the owner receives the paperwork simply and accurately.
  • Touch Data: Come with the owner’s touch knowledge for any questions or clarifications.

Pattern Landlord’s Letter Soliciting for Financial institution Statements

This pattern letter demonstrates a legally sound and transparent manner.

Expensive [Tenant Name],This letter officially requests financial institution statements to ensure your monetary skill to fulfill your condominium responsibilities. As in keeping with our hire settlement, this can be a usual process to evaluate the tenant’s monetary balance.Please supply financial institution statements overlaying the duration from [Start Date] to [End Date] through [Date]. The statements must be submitted by the use of e-mail to [Email Address] in PDF structure.Sincerely,[Landlord Name][Landlord Contact Information]

Pattern Tenant’s Letter Rejecting Unreasonable Request

This case highlights how a tenant can reject an unreasonable request.

Expensive [Landlord Name],Thanks to your letter dated [Date]. Whilst I perceive the desire for monetary verification, the request for financial institution statements overlaying the duration from [Start Date] to [End Date] is overly wide and past the scope of our hire settlement.I’m prepared to offer [Alternative Documentation] as a type of verification, which is in step with prison pointers and tenant rights. Sincerely,[Tenant Name][Tenant Contact Information]

An important Components and Prison Necessities

This desk summarizes the important thing parts and prison concerns for a landlord’s letter asking for financial institution statements.

Part Description Prison Attention
Objective Obviously state the cause of the request. Will have to be a valid industry objective associated with the tenancy.
Time-frame Specify an affordable time frame for submission. Steer clear of unduly burdensome requests.
Directions Obviously give an explanation for easy methods to put up the statements. Make sure readability and keep away from ambiguity.
Touch Data Supply touch knowledge for explanation. Facilitates conversation and determination of problems.

Absolute best Practices for Landlords and Tenants: Can A Landlord Ask For Financial institution Statements

Navigating the method of asking for and offering financial institution statements calls for a gentle stability of prison compliance, transparency, and mutual appreciate between landlords and tenants. Transparent conversation and adherence to highest practices are the most important to forestall misunderstandings and deal with a favorable landlord-tenant courting. This phase Artikels particular pointers for each events to verify a clean and legally sound procedure.

Landlord Absolute best Practices

Correctly asking for financial institution statements is the most important for a landlord to evaluate a tenant’s monetary balance and skill to satisfy condominium responsibilities. This procedure should be treated with due diligence and prison consciousness.

  • Obviously State the Explanation why for the Request: The owner must obviously articulate the cause of asking for financial institution statements. A basic request for monetary balance is inadequate. For instance, a request associated with a particular worry, like a past due hire charge, must be obviously mentioned within the request letter.
  • Take care of Transparency: Transparency is essential. Landlords must give an explanation for the aim of reviewing the statements and the way the tips will probably be used with regards to the tenancy settlement.
  • Prohibit the Scope of the Request: Steer clear of soliciting for pointless main points. Request most effective the tips without delay related to comparing the tenant’s monetary capability to pay hire. A particular period of time (e.g., the ultimate 3 months) is the most important for a centered request.
  • Conform to Prison Necessities: Landlords should adhere to all appropriate state and native regulations in regards to the assortment and use of tenant monetary knowledge. This contains privateness regulations and rules on monetary information.
  • Take care of Confidentiality: Deal with the financial institution statements as confidential paperwork. Make sure they’re treated securely and saved in step with prison necessities. Don’t percentage the statements with unauthorized people.

Tenant Absolute best Practices

Responding to a landlord’s request for financial institution statements comes to working out your rights and responsibilities.

  • Assessment the Request Sparsely: Sparsely read about the owner’s request for readability and make sure it aligns with the phrases of the hire settlement. If the request turns out overly wide or unreasonable, visit prison suggest.
  • Give you the Asked Data Promptly: Reply to the request inside of an affordable time frame, making sure all required knowledge is incorporated. At all times apply the precise directions Artikeld within the request.
  • Take care of Correct Information: Stay copies of all submitted financial institution statements and any correspondence associated with the request. This documentation is very important in case of disputes.
  • Offer protection to Your Privateness: Pay attention to your proper to privateness. Don’t supply knowledge past what’s explicitly asked. Make sure the tips you supply is correct.
  • Search Prison Recommendation if Vital: You probably have considerations concerning the legality of the request, visit a prison skilled to grasp your rights and choices.

Making sure Prison Compliance

Each landlords and tenants should perceive and conform to related regulations to deal with a legally sound procedure.

  • Assessment Appropriate Regulations: Landlords must overview all related state and native regulations governing landlord-tenant relationships and monetary knowledge. Tenants must even be accustomed to those regulations.
  • Seek the advice of Prison Suggest if Wanted: Looking for prison recommendation for each landlords and tenants is really useful, particularly in complicated scenarios. That is the most important in making sure compliance with rules.
  • Report All Verbal exchange: All conversation in regards to the request for financial institution statements, together with the preliminary request and the reaction, must be documented. That is the most important for dispute answer.

Significance of Verbal exchange and Transparency

Open and clear conversation is very important for a wholesome landlord-tenant courting. Fair conversation minimizes attainable misunderstandings and fosters believe.

  • Take care of Open Discussion: Determine transparent traces of conversation. This contains responding promptly to inquiries and addressing any considerations.
  • Proactive Verbal exchange: Await attainable problems and cope with them promptly. Transparency builds believe and is helping to get to the bottom of issues earlier than they escalate.

Abstract of Absolute best Practices

Side Landlord Absolute best Practices Tenant Absolute best Practices
Request Readability Obviously state the cause of the request and objective of overview. Assessment the request sparsely for readability and reasonableness.
Transparency Give an explanation for the aim and use of the tips. Perceive your proper to privateness and most effective supply asked knowledge.
Prison Compliance Adhere to all appropriate regulations referring to tenant monetary knowledge. Conform to the request inside of an affordable time frame and give protection to your data.
Verbal exchange Take care of open conversation and cope with considerations promptly. Reply promptly to inquiries and cope with any considerations.

Case Research and Examples

Landlords often request financial institution statements from tenants, ceaselessly as a measure to evaluate monetary balance. On the other hand, the legality and appropriateness of those requests range considerably in line with the precise instances and jurisdiction. This phase supplies real-world examples let’s say a hit and unsuccessful requests, highlighting prison demanding situations and attainable defenses.

A success Financial institution Remark Requests, Can a landlord ask for financial institution statements

Landlords in the hunt for to ensure a tenant’s skill to pay hire can ceaselessly use financial institution statements to show a tenant’s constant source of revenue and monetary capability. Those requests, when correctly justified, can give a contribution to a extra safe condominium settlement. For instance, a landlord may use financial institution statements to establish a tenant’s stable source of revenue move from employment, successfully mitigating the chance of past due or non-payment.

Landlords ceaselessly need evidence of your monetary balance, however can they call for financial institution statements? The specifics range, however it is the most important to grasp native regulations and tenant rights. For the ones in Clearwater, Florida, suffering with meals lack of confidence, assets like food banks in Clearwater Florida be offering essential fortify. In the long run, working out your rights as a tenant referring to monetary documentation is essential to a clean condominium procedure.

The a hit use of financial institution statements in such scenarios is predicated closely at the readability of the request and the tenant’s cooperation.

Landlords can request monetary knowledge, however the specifics range through area and scenario. Whilst a landlord may no longer automatically call for financial institution statements, it is price bearing in mind if a live-in particular person should buy existence insurance coverage on their condominium, doubtlessly impacting monetary balance. can a live-in person buy life insurance on their apartment This ceaselessly hinges on hire agreements and native rules.

In the long run, the power for a landlord to invite for financial institution statements ceaselessly comes right down to prison pointers and the main points of the precise scenario.

Unsuccessful Financial institution Remark Requests

Conversely, no longer all requests for financial institution statements are legally sound. A landlord’s request could be deemed invalid if it lacks a valid foundation, as an example, whether it is used for discriminatory functions or to research private monetary issues unrelated to condominium responsibilities. A tenant who has a valid reason why for denying a financial institution remark request, corresponding to a priority about privateness violations or the request’s loss of transparent justification, may effectively withstand a landlord’s call for.

Prison Demanding situations Related to Financial institution Remark Requests

A number of prison demanding situations can rise up when asking for or offering financial institution statements. Those come with considerations about privateness violations, discrimination, and the relevance of the tips asked to the condominium settlement. As an example, a landlord’s request for detailed private monetary knowledge past hire charge capability could be deemed an invasion of privateness. In a similar fashion, a request in line with discriminatory components, corresponding to race or faith, may just face prison demanding situations beneath anti-discrimination regulations.

Eviction In response to Financial institution Statements

A landlord in the hunt for to evict a tenant may try to use financial institution statements as proof of monetary irresponsibility. For instance, a tenant who persistently presentations inadequate finances of their account could be thought to be a chance through the owner. On the other hand, this manner faces important prison hurdles. The owner should show a transparent connection between the tenant’s monetary scenario and their breach of the condominium settlement.

The owner should additionally end up that the tenant’s movements represent a contravention of the hire settlement, corresponding to repeated past due hire bills. Tenants have the precise to give proof to counter the owner’s claims, doubtlessly demonstrating instances like a brief monetary hardship or a valid reason why for the inadequate finances. If a tenant can effectively show that the monetary problems are brief or unrelated to the hire settlement, an eviction primarily based only on financial institution statements may well be challenged and in the long run unsuccessful.

Final Phrase

Jadi, kalau dapat permintaan financial institution remark dari landlord, penting banget cek dulu dasar hukumnya. Jangan asal iya aja, bisa-bisa kena masalah. Kalau ada yang nggak jelas, cari bantuan ahli hukum. Intinya, komunikasi yang baik dan saling menghormati antara penyewa dan landlord itu kunci utama. Jangan sampai karena masalah ini, hubungan jadi tegang.

FAQ Insights

Apakah landlord bisa meminta semua element transaksi financial institution saya?

Tidak semua element transaksi bisa diminta. Yang penting cuma hal-hal yang berkaitan dengan kemampuan membayar sewa, bukan element keuangan pribadi lainnya.

Berapa lama landlord bisa minta financial institution remark?

Biasanya dalam waktu yang wajar, sesuai dengan perjanjian sewa menyewa. Jangan sampai landlord minta terlalu lama, karena bisa jadi nggak sah.

Apa yang harus saya lakukan kalau landlord minta financial institution remark yang nggak wajar?

Konsultasikan dengan ahli hukum. Jangan langsung setuju, karena bisa jadi permintaannya nggak sesuai aturan. Jangan sampai kena masalah hukum, kan sayang.

Apa konsekuensi kalau landlord minta financial institution remark dengan cara yang salah?

Bisa jadi perjanjian sewa menyewa dibatalkan atau kena denda. Makanya penting banget untuk teliti.

Leave a Comment